This cosy spot on Hoxton Square used to be Petit Pois Bistro.
But it’s now – happily – Everafter.
It’s still run by the same team, who are also behind the highly recommended cocktail bar Happiness Forgets (which you’ll find just downstairs). Petit Pois was the restaurant wing of the operation, and it was good. If anything, it was a little too good – because when it scored a coveted Michelin Bib Gourmand, the place was swamped with bookings from punters expecting a fine dining experience, as opposed to the warm, relaxed, neighbourhood dining it did so well. So the team decided, Lyaness-style, to switch everything up and try something new, gearing up to open Everafter in March 2020.
And we all know how that story ended.
Now, having weathered the pandemic, it’s properly up and running – and what an absolute beauty it is. Somehow, in the middle of one of the busiest, most raucous patches of town, they’ve created a laid-back bar and eatery that feels like your local.
The decor’s largely unchanged from its previous incarnation, with exposed brick walls and pea-green tiles; high, marble-topped tables; and stools lining the long bar-top that runs almost the length of the space. By day, the outside tables overlooking the leafy square make for a peaceful aperitivo spot; by night, candles are lit and the place takes on a more romantic, intimate tone.
So how about the drinks? Well, sure, you could come here for a crisp pint at the end of a long day, or pluck a bottle from the unusual wine rack clinging to one of the walls. But really, it would be criminal not to try one of the cocktails. Unsurprisingly for a sibling of Happiness Forgets, Everafter does some truly fantastic drinks – ingredients are inventive without sounding inedible; and each concoction will give you change from a tenner.
The line-up changes regularly, but a couple of house favourites likely to stick around include the martini, made to the Dukes recipe but toned down so you can actually stand up afterwards; a peach and sherry cobbler, which feels like the more sophisticated cousin to an Aperol spritz; and a Blueberry Negroni, flush with blueberry-infused gin and a French dessert wine. They’re accompanied by a roster of specials like the Bavarian Sour, with red vermouth, crème de banane and cardamom.
It would, however, be remiss not to mention the food here. The dishes are absolutely flawless. Head chef Joni Ketonen came here from Pantechnicon, and brings his experience in Michelin-starred kitchens to bear on elegantly presented and beautifully balanced small plates like steak tartare with breadcrumbs and crispy kale; melt-in-the-mouth aubergine custard (sounds odd, tastes like heaven); and delicate seabass ceviche.
He’s got raw talent.
NOTE: Everafter is open daily. You can find out more, and book, HERE.
Everafter | 9 Hoxton Square, London N1 6NU
Spend a lot of time in East London? Check out our guide to the best bars in Shoreditch
The Nudge is an independent, searchable and highly-curated guide to the most interesting places to go and things to do in London, giving members unrestricted access to our full compendium of continually-updated restaurants, bars, events, exhibitions, date ideas, itineraries, member perks, weekend guides, monthly agendas and more – all delivered via our website, email newsletters & members’ app.
Join us to see what’s hot in London this week; to explore all of the recommendations & ideas stored within The Nudge’s website and members’ app; and to start making the most of life in London today. Start Free One Week Trial